Stack Rock Group : Landscape Architecture : Boise ID and Salt Lake City UT

Recent News

Is Design At A Paradigm Shift?

landscape architect, boise idaho

By: Jesse Buster

In a recent ArchDaily article Steven Holl claims “It’s not a great moment, there are a lot of bad architects,” attributing to his successes of award winning projects.

This reminds me of the 2014 ArchDaily article where Frank Gehry claimed that Today’s Architecture is (Mostly) “Pure Shit.” He alleges only 2% of everything built is not pure shit.

“Let me tell you one thing. In this world we are living in, 98 percent of everything that is built and designed today is pure shit. There’s no sense of design, no respect for humanity or for anything else. They are damn buildings and that’s it.”

“Once in a while, however, there’s a small group of people who does something special. Very few. But good god, leave us alone! We are dedicated to our work. I don’t ask for work. I don’t have a publicist. I’m not waiting for anyone to call me. I work with clients who respect the art of architecture. Therefore, please don’t ask questions as stupid as that one.”

Frank Gehry
Photo from ArchDaily

I’m inspired by Holl’s process of exploration and letting the spirit unfold, from water color studies, to 3D exploration through fruition of something hopefully timeless. That function and program come from the feeling of space, something Landscape Architects (and many others) refer to as Genus Loci ‘spirit of place’, to be cliche.

My question (which I’m working to educate myself, and hopefully be further educated about) is whether this is truly a problem as perceived by our predecessors, or simply a symptom of today’s climate. Are our challenges of today’s aggressive market and somewhat marital slavery to our craft different than they have experienced? Or are we at a paradigm shift, to reclaim the integrity of our professions?

Could it merely be a numbers game regarding many more people practicing and just going through the motions? Or is it simply that we as a whole have regressed with the exponential growth in technology and rapid development? I haven’t the answer and I know I’m not the first to touch on this.

There are so many factors, and a blanket statement is never something to take to heart, but their claims have merit regarding the adaptability and resilience of a craft over time. Not everyone has the benefit to pick their clients, and I’m not going to assume that designers aren’t standing strong in their own truth of taking care of a client to deliver something within their monetary and time restrictions; working within strict parameters.

It’s not always just about design, its also about customer service and providing for our families with a strong sense of responsibility, and a tiptoe approach to liability.

There are bad doctors, bad teachers, bad apples, and of course those practicing designers who the occupation is simply not suited for. We’re fortunate to team with so many professionals who truly emulate what architecture is. All of us here at Stack Rock Group continually aim to achieve that on the side of site and land. Hopefully our efforts are blindingly apparent. I truly believe most do their best with the information available at hand, understanding there’s room for humility, growth, and a desire to push the (alleged) 2% higher.

Perhaps we really are at a paradigm shift, where we must push back and reclaim timelessness in our craft and products. Where space and place are synonymous, materials aren’t just a cost effective after thought, and it continues to become about the human, and not a result of the market variables.

What are your thoughts? I look forward to any feedback.

-Buster